Skip to content
INDUS
All current affairs

Mains Corner

Healthcare for All: Why Price Caps on Cancer Drugs Are Not Enough

GS mapping: GS-2 (Health, Welfare schemes, Governance) | GS-3 (Economy: health financing, Inclusive growth) | GS-4 (Ethics: equity, public good) | Essay

Why in news: An op-ed by Usha Thorat (former RBI Deputy Governor) and Nachiket Mor (health economist) argues that price caps alone will not make cancer care affordable. It follows the Supreme Court's observations on drug mark-ups, where a cancer medicine sold to a retailer for about ₹2,700 carried an MRP of ₹27,000. New data from National Health Accounts (NHA) 2023-24 (released 15 November 2026) show that households still pay 42.7% of health spending from their own pockets.

What the data say

  • Government health spending rose from about ₹1.30 lakh crore (2013-14) to ₹4.14 lakh crore (2023-24), about 3.2 times. Per capita government spending rose from ₹1,042 to ₹2,959.
  • Out-of-pocket expenditure (OOPE) fell from 64.2% to 42.7% of total health expenditure. It was 43.4% in 2022-23, so it rose slightly in the latest year.
  • Social security rose from 6% to 11% and private health insurance from 3.4% to 10.2% of health spending.
  • Cancer shows why OOPE stays high. A Tata Memorial study of gastric and pancreatic cancer patients found an average travel distance of 1,475 km and about ₹88,000 of non-medical spending, apart from treatment.

Why price caps are not enough

  • Information gap: a patient cannot judge a drug's price or need, and has little bargaining power. Price regulation corrects this, but only for the drugs it covers.
  • Costs beyond medicines: travel, stay, lost wages and caregivers' time can exceed drug costs.
  • Late diagnosis: cancers found late need costlier treatment with poorer results.
  • Fragmented buyers: each patient buys alone, so suppliers keep their power.

The healthcare-for-all angle

Universal Health Coverage (UHC) means that all people get the health services they need, of good quality, without financial hardship (WHO; SDG 3.8). Cancer care tests each part of UHC:

  1. Prevent: tobacco control, HPV vaccination against cervical cancer, and screening in primary care. Regional patterns (for example, smoked and fermented food and nasopharyngeal cancer in the Northeast) call for targeted prevention.
  2. Detect early: the primary health centre can spot risk, refer, and keep a patient in continuity. Early diagnosis is cheaper and saves lives.
  3. Treat nearby: a stepped-care network. District hospitals give diagnostics, supportive care and simple infusions. Tertiary centres handle surgery and radiotherapy. The National Cancer Grid (NCG) links over 300 centres that treat about two-thirds of India's cancer cases.
  4. Pay smartly: Ayushman Bharat PM-JAY (cover of ₹5 lakh per family a year) should use its scale to buy strategically: negotiate prices, require treatment protocols, and shape referral. This is purchasing, not only reimbursement.
  5. Protect survivors: insurers often refuse or overcharge people with an old cancer diagnosis. The op-ed suggests a Right to be Forgotten after a disease-free interval and risk pooling.
  6. Fill the gaps: non-profits and funds, for example the Indian Cancer Society's Cancer Cure Fund (over 18,000 patients, over ₹340 crore), can help, but should supplement the system.

Lessons from outside India

  • Thailand: the Universal Coverage Scheme (introduced 2001 to 2002, popularly the "30-baht scheme") covered the previously uninsured population through tax funding. A national purchaser pays hospitals mainly by capitation and fixed rates and controls drug prices through bulk buying. Out-of-pocket spending and catastrophic health costs fell sharply. The lesson: strategic purchasing by a single large buyer.
  • Germany: the op-ed notes that multiple insurers negotiate collectively with suppliers, including on drug prices. This pooled bargaining counters supplier power.
  • France and Australia (cited in the op-ed): France's rules protect old cancer patients' access to insurance after a defined disease-free period; Australia uses risk equalisation among private insurers.
  • Integrated models such as Kaiser Permanente (US) and Clalit (Israel) bring financing and care together, so prevention and continuity pay off.

Challenges in India

  • Low public spending: the National Health Policy, 2017 aimed at public health spending of 2.5% of GDP by 2025.
  • Uneven capacity: cancer centres cluster in big cities, so patients travel far.
  • Insurance gaps: hospitalisation cover does not meet outpatient diagnostics, drugs and travel costs.
  • Regulation: weaker oversight of private providers and drug margins; caps can be bypassed.
  • Federalism: health is a State subject, so success depends on State capacity.

Way forward

  • Raise and pool public funds, and make PM-JAY a strategic purchaser.
  • Strengthen primary care and screening, and link district hospitals with NCG centres.
  • Regulate prices where bargaining power is weak, and use bulk procurement (as in the NCG) elsewhere.
  • Cover outpatient care and travel costs for chronic diseases.
  • Protect survivors through a Right to be Forgotten and risk pooling.
  • Use data and digital health records (Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission) to track patients and quality.

Conclusion

Price caps can stop the worst abuse, but the aim is not just to find more money to pay India's cancer bill, but to change the system so that the bill is smaller, and its shock is shared. Healthcare for all means prevention, nearby care and pooled purchasing, so that no family sinks into poverty because of illness.

Mains toolkit

Keywords: out-of-pocket expenditure, catastrophic health expenditure, strategic purchasing, risk pooling, stepped care, primary healthcare, National Cancer Grid, SDG 3.8, Right to be Forgotten, capitation

Practice questions

  1. "Price control alone cannot make healthcare affordable." Discuss with reference to cancer care in India. (150 words, 10 marks)
  2. Examine the challenges in achieving Universal Health Coverage in India. How can strategic purchasing under Ayushman Bharat improve financial protection? (250 words, 15 marks)

Get the full month in one PDF

The Current Affairs Monthly covers every important item in English and Telugu, with Group 1 points.

Browse current affairs material